Rethinking Collaboration: A Spectrum of Collaboration for Public Sector Organisations

By Clive Martlew While collaboration is widely promoted within public sector reform initiatives, there is strong research evidence and hard-earned experience showing that deep, formal collaboration is complex, resource-intensive, slow to deliver, and often inappropriate for many challenges. Over-reliance on the language of collaboration can lead to pseudo-collaboration—structures and meetings that mask continued fragmentation and friction rather than delivering real change. So, while deep collaboration may be the appropriate and indeed only solution for certain major public service challenges a focus on such structural and institutional changes can crowd out other more productive approaches.
To address this, I’ve found it useful to think of collaboration as a spectrum, expressed through a 6Cs model, which provides a practical framework for choosing the right form of joint working for the right problem. The model recognises six distinct modes of working together and emphasises the value of partners working together to build a portfolio of approaches - ranging from deep integration to light-touch interaction and constructive rivalry - that can evolve over time.

At the most intensive end, Collaborate and Co-create involves full-scale, formal partnerships with shared governance, pooled budgets, joint teams, and co-designed services. This approach is appropriate where problems are systemic, outcomes are tightly interdependent, and fragmented delivery would significantly harm results. While it offers clear benefits such as unified priorities, scale efficiencies, and improved user experience, it also carries substantial risks, including complex change management, legal constraints, and potential loss of organisational identity.
Moving down the spectrum, Cooperation and Resource-Sharing allows organisations to retain autonomy while selectively sharing assets, infrastructure such as IT platforms, business support functions and common services to improve efficiency and resilience. It is often designed around contracts, MOUs or Service Level Agreements. Sharing is a useful option when there are skills shortages, clear duplication of functions, and predictable and standardised processes. It can lead to better use of assets, improved resilience and access to scarce skills. However, it can also create a perceived loss of control and responsiveness, inter-organisational disputes and dissatisfaction and consequent “shadow duplication” where the collaborating organisations retain certain capabilities (e.g. HR) in disguised (and costly) forms (e.g. as generic business support functions).
Coordination of Activities focuses on aligning and deconflicting plans, schedules, sequencing and timing (e.g. of inspections, consultations, events or announcements), locations and geographical focus, and roles to avoid duplication and clashes, reduce overlap, and ensure that gaps in provision are filled. Each party executes its own mandate, but coordination improves service coherence, public understanding and user experiences without requiring shared resources or governance.
Lighter still are processes of Consultation and Alignment of Interests where organisations engage early and routinely to seek and incorporate each other’s views and consider impacts on partners when making decisions. The focus may be on consultations around major strategy or policy changes or major announcements and initiatives. The goal is to prevent conflict and unproductive competitiveness, ensure compatibility of policies, improve policy and service design, reduce “boundary disputes”, avoid confusion and inconvenience for service users, and remain mindful of shared or overlapping stakeholder groups. The benefits of effective consultation emerge through fewer unintended consequences, smoother implementation and increased public confidence and legitimacy. The risks include wasting time on what are often perceived as “tick‑box” exercises when decisions have already been taken (e.g. late engagement when options are closed) and consultation fatigue.
Communication, Information-Sharing and Joint Learning, which provides the essential foundation for trust, situational awareness, and continuous improvement across the system. We can frame this approach as being about knowledge management. It’s a light-touch but essential form of collaboration and probably foundational for other more complex modes. The regular exchange of information, insights, expertise, experience, data, and best practices helps organisations learn, make informed decisions and maintain awareness of each other’s work. It also reduces surprises, spreads innovation, builds trust and reinforces a culture of collaboration. Some typical approaches could include joint research or benchmarking exercises, establishing facilitated Professional Networks and Communities of Practice, peer reviews and learning exchanges and joint training such as leadership development.
Finally, it’s also worth including the idea of Constructive Competition. uses transparent performance comparison, recognition and celebration of excellence, and challenge to stimulate innovation and performance improvement. This is competitive but supportive, encouraging improvement rather than aggressive rivalry. Use of league tables, awards and recognition programmes, challenges funds and competitions to spur improvement while enabling learning from top performers. Constructive competition of course requires strong safeguards and governance to ensure fairness and learning rather than gaming and blaming.
Building a Collaboration Portfolio
A central message of the 6Cs model is that no single mode is inherently superior. Effective public sector collaboration requires the ability to move up and down the spectrum over time, combine modes intelligently, and maintain a balanced portfolio of collaborative approaches aligned to strategic goals, risk appetite, and delivery context. Used in this way, the spectrum helps manage expectations, reduces unnecessary collaborative burden, and focuses scarce leadership and organisational capacity where deep collaboration is truly required, while still enabling meaningful progress through lighter, more agile forms of working together.

Written by Cliver Martlew, Taylor Clarke Consultant



